This 2017 rendering shows a three-story, 30 apartment building facing Oakcrest Road with 54 parking spaces. Wetlands have been greatly reduced, and a bird sanctuary is no longer contemplated. Village of Lansing Planning Board members said in no uncertain terms Tuesday that they would not approve the most recent incarnation of the Lansing Meadows project that would bring rental senior housing to the Shops at Ithaca Mall. The project, originally 12 units in cottage-style buildings intended for rental to seniors, a wetlands area and bird sanctuary, was part of a plan to make the construction of a big box store to the north of the mall palatable to the Village, and to provide a buffer from the commercial area and a gradual transition from the high density commercial area to residential neighborhoods north of Oakcrest Road. Planning Board members said they had been tolerant of delays, changes to the plan, and even a small commercial area they did not want, but the latest design was unacceptable.
"What I see now is, you got BJ's, which you cashed out of; you now want and have obtained permission to put in a coffee shop; now you want us to say, 'nah, we don't want those cottages to look like residences. We'll take a big building'," Planning Board member Deborah Dawson told developer Eric Goetzmann Tuesday. "No habitat. No wetlands. No good looking green space. Just another big blocky building. No transition. As far as I'm concerned, what this thing looks like now is not at all what the PDA envisioned. Not at all what the IDA thought they were getting. Not a transition. Not a neighborhood. And not anything that really meets the requirements of the Comprehensive Plan. So, as far as I'm concerned, my answer to all of this is no. I want what we bargained for in the first place."