Legislature Fails to Affirm Support for Single-Payer Health-CareAsked to reaffirm its earlier actions in 2006 and 2009, the Legislature failed to take a stand voicing continued support for a single-payer approach to health care coverage in New York State. Acting on a measure advanced by Legislator Kathy Luz Herrera that would have urged the State Assembly and Senate to pass legislation to enact the New York Health Act that would support universal health coverage, the Legislature voted 7-4 in favor which, while a majority, did not draw the 8 votes needed for passage. (Legislators Dave McKenna, Glenn Morey, Mike Sigler, and Peter Stein voted no; Legislators Jim Dennis, Will Burbank, and Carol Chock were excused.) The measure, however, could be brought up for reconsideration at a future meeting, and Legislator Luz Herrera said she would be speaking in favor of it again at the Legislature's next meeting June 2, when she hopes the Legislature can discuss the issue in more detail.
Before the vote, Luz Herrera said the time has come to move from the multi-payer approach to a "simple, one-stop single-payer system for all," that overall health care spending would be reduced and that 98% of New Yorkers would pay less for health care than they do today. Legislator Sigler said that there are too many uncertainties in the proposals and assumptions that he's not sure are true, saying the resolution indicates that the Affordable Care Act has failed and a new system should be adopted. While saying he's not necessarily for or against a single-payer system, Legislator Stein said the matter is complicated and he fears it is being "oversold", and termed it "madness" to leave the Affordable Care Act at this point. While he voted in favor, Legislator Nate Shinagawa, a health care administrator, noted that the current fee-for-service system for health care is not sustainable. "You need to have fundamental change to make single-payer work," he said.